Mortgage Recast vs. Refinance: Which Is Right for You?
Both a recast and a refinance can lower your mortgage payment, but one costs a few hundred dollars and keeps your rate, while the other can cost thousands and replaces your loan entirely. Here's how to tell which one fits your situation.
Recast and refinance in one sentence each
A mortgage recast (also called re-amortization) is when you pay a lump sum toward principal and your lender recalculates your monthly payment over the remaining term, at the same interest rate. You keep your loan; only the payment changes.
A refinance replaces your loan with a brand-new one: new rate, new term, new closing costs, and a new approval process with a credit check and usually an appraisal.
Both can lower your monthly payment. They do it in completely different ways, cost very different amounts, and make sense in different situations.
Side-by-side comparison
| Recast | Refinance | |
|---|---|---|
| Interest rate | Stays the same | New rate (higher or lower) |
| Loan term | Stays the same | Usually resets (often to 30 years) |
| Upfront cost | Typically a flat fee of about $150 to $500 | Closing costs, often 2% to 6% of the loan |
| Cash required | A lump sum, often a $5,000 to $10,000 minimum | None beyond closing costs (unless you pay down the balance) |
| Credit check / appraisal | Usually not | Yes |
| Time to complete | Days to a few weeks | Often 30 to 45 days |
| Available on | Many conventional loans; generally not FHA, VA or USDA | Almost any loan, if you qualify |
How a recast works
- Ask your servicer whether your loan can be recast, what the minimum lump sum is, and what the fee is. Policies vary widely, and some servicers don't offer it at all.
- Make the principal payment. Many servicers want it labeled as a recast payment, not a regular extra payment.
- Sign the recast agreement and pay the fee. Your new, lower payment usually takes effect within one or two billing cycles.
Recasts are especially common after selling a previous home. If you bought your new home before the old one sold, you can put the sale proceeds toward the new mortgage and bring the payment down to what you'd have had with a bigger down payment, without giving up your rate.
The same $30,000, three ways
Say you owe $280,000 at 6.5% with 26 years (312 payments) left. Your principal and interest payment is about $1,862. You have $30,000 you could put toward the mortgage.
| Option | New monthly payment | Loan paid off in | Interest from here on |
|---|---|---|---|
| Do nothing | $1,862 | 26 years | $300,900 |
| Recast with $30,000 | $1,662 (−$199) | 26 years | $268,600 |
| Prepay $30,000, keep paying $1,862 | $1,862 | about 20 years | $197,900 |
The table shows the real trade-off. A recast buys monthly breathing room: $199 less every month for the rest of the loan. A prepayment without recasting buys the biggest interest savings: same payment, but the loan ends about six years sooner and you avoid roughly $70,000 more in interest than with the recast.
You can also do a middle path: recast to lock in the lower required payment, then keep paying the old amount voluntarily. You get nearly the same interest savings as a straight prepayment, plus the flexibility to drop back to the lower payment if money gets tight.
The Mortgage Recast Calculator compares recasting, prepaying and refinancing with your own loan details.
When refinancing is the better move
Refinancing makes sense when you can get a meaningfully lower rate, because it changes the price of every dollar you owe, not just the dollars you pay off. To judge it, use the break-even test:
Continuing the example: if rates fall and you can refinance the $280,000 into a new 30-year loan at 5.75%, your payment drops to about $1,634, saving $228 a month. With closing costs of 3% ($8,400), you break even in about 37 months. If you'll keep the home well beyond three years, the refinance pays for itself.
But look closer at total interest: stretching 26 remaining years back out to 30 means about $308,200 of interest over the new loan, slightly more than the $300,900 you'd pay by doing nothing, despite the lower rate. Refinancing into a shorter term (or keeping your old payment after refinancing) avoids that trap.
Refinancing can also be the right tool if you need to remove a co-borrower, switch from an adjustable rate to a fixed rate, or get rid of FHA mortgage insurance by moving to a conventional loan.
Which should you choose?
Recast if…
- Your current rate is lower than or close to today's rates, so refinancing wouldn't improve it.
- You've come into a lump sum (a home sale, bonus or inheritance) and want a lower required payment.
- You want to avoid closing costs, a credit check and a new appraisal.
- Your loan is conventional and your servicer allows recasting.
Refinance if…
- Rates have dropped enough that you'll pass the break-even point well before you expect to move or pay off the loan.
- You don't have a large lump sum, but want a lower payment.
- You need to change the loan itself: drop FHA mortgage insurance, remove a borrower, or move from an adjustable rate to a fixed rate.
Do neither if…
- The lump sum is your emergency fund. Money inside your house is hard to get back out quickly.
- You have higher-interest debt, such as credit cards. Paying that off first almost always wins.
- You could earn more by investing than your mortgage rate costs you, and you're comfortable with the risk. The Pay Off Mortgage or Invest Calculator helps you compare.
Questions to ask your servicer
- Does my loan qualify for a recast? If not, why?
- What is the minimum lump sum, and what is the fee?
- Does my loan need to be a certain age, or current on payments?
- How many times can I recast over the life of the loan?
- How long until the new payment takes effect, and will my escrow change?
Frequently asked questions
Does recasting a mortgage lower the interest rate?
No. A recast keeps your interest rate and remaining term the same. It lowers your monthly payment because it recalculates the payment on a smaller balance.
How much does a mortgage recast cost?
Most servicers charge a flat fee, commonly between about $150 and $500, and require a minimum lump-sum principal payment, often $5,000 to $10,000 or a percentage of the balance.
Can you recast an FHA or VA loan?
Generally no. FHA, VA and USDA loans usually can't be recast. Recasting is mainly available on conventional loans, depending on your servicer's policy.
Is it better to recast or pay extra on my mortgage?
Extra payments without a recast save more interest and pay the loan off sooner, but your required payment stays the same. A recast lowers the required payment but saves less interest. You can recast and still choose to pay the old amount.
Does a recast affect my credit score?
A recast typically doesn't require a credit check, so it usually doesn't affect your score. A refinance involves a hard credit inquiry and a new loan account.
Sources
This guide is general education, not financial, tax or legal advice. Rules and limits change; confirm details with your lender, the IRS, the Social Security Administration or a qualified professional before acting. Spot an error? Tell us and we'll fix it.